(Sylvia Batty), Author provided
The Smithsonian Museum of African Art recently announced its intent to repatriate Benin Bronzes to Nigeria. Similar news stories of returning “stolen” or “removed” items of historical and cultural value are becoming more common.
Benin bronzes: What is the significance of their repatriation to Nigeria?
Stories covering repatriation of belongings by colonial institutions back to their communities of origin tend to go two ways. They contemplate the opinions surrounding and the legal frameworks involved in returning such belongings. Or they challenge our perceptions of colonial institutions like museums.
People who write stories like these often invoke Erik Killmonger’s powerful remarks about stolen artifacts in Black Panther: “How do you think your ancestors got these? Do you think they paid a fair price? Or did they take it, like they took everything else?” More commonly, they point to Indiana Jones’ now famous declaration, “That belongs in a museum!”
As archeologists and heritage specialists from Canada and Belize, we offer an alternative commentary. We focus on communities of origin as agents of change both globally and locally.
Material past in the living present
Nations and people are increasingly participating in everyday actions of decolonization and reconciliation, of which repatriation is just one element.
But what’s more important are acts of local engagement and community-based initiatives in culture and heritage. These help pivot our understanding of the material past in the living present and work to break down power structures that intrude on peoples’ rights and paths to self-determination.
Local engagement and community-based initiatives negotiate relationships that seek to reimagine colonial political systems and foster empowerment for local benefit. They also aim to avoid recreating past power imbalances, and amplify diverse voices in storytelling.
(Shawn Morton), Author provided
The case of Belize
Belize is a former colony of Britain, now a multicultural and independent country, and has been pursuing relatively quiet acts of repatriation for decades. The country has also engaged in high-profile demands for restitution.
Community members work alongside Belizean and foreign archeologists at the local level to ensure that what led to the initial removal of material culture never happens again.
An early Belizean initiative involved the establishment of temporary and longer-term loan programs with foreign institutions. One of the first was with the Royal Ontario Museum (ROM) and the country’s legally excavated archeological collection from the ancient Maya city of Altun Ha, which has since been mostly repatriated. Additional artifacts remain on loan and form the centrepiece of the ROM’s Maya collection and associated exhibits.
The Belizean government established the national Museum of Belize in 2002 following these early repatriations. Museum representatives and officials from the Institute of Archaeology arrange regular countrywide tours because not all citizens can readily access the museum.
They do this because access to tangible heritage — including artifacts that have been repatriated — helps connect people to the past and to their identities. This is essential to rebuilding and reimagining post-colonial Belize.
Belizean organizers and foreign archeologist-collaborators often pair these tours with locally planned cultural activities, like the Succotz Archaeology and Culture Fair that enables residents from smaller communities across Belize to engage with their people’s belongings and history, making it a part of their daily lives.
(Rebecca Newberry), Author provided
Establishing small community museums and cultural centres across the country is important because it allows communities the chance to highlight stories of their particular locales.
These organizations also participate in associated community-based heritage and cultural research, with, by and for Indigenous, descendant and local communities. The Crooked Tree Museum and Cultural Heritage Centre is a great example of a community-led educational initiative and research program that does just that.
Crooked Tree explores the deep and shifting history of the lower Belize River watershed, from the first local peoples over 10,000 years ago to the Creole community of today.
Accompanying items abroad
Professionally trained Belizeans now accompany heritage and cultural items when they leave the country for museums abroad. These individuals are active participants in recounting the artifacts’ life stories. They also ensure the items are appropriately cared for and respected physically and culturally.
In the recent travelling exhibit of Maya: Hidden Worlds Revealed, Belizeans acted as couriers and primary decision-makers. Along the way they have benefited from additional hands-on training in diverse exhibition and curation practices.
Making kin not cash: repatriations of substance cannot be made on terms that solely suit European museums
While these everyday initiatives aim to break down colonial power structures both at home and abroad, they are far from perfect. Issues of heritage and culture are fraught with complex power and identity struggles.
They can simultaneously trigger legal battles while also inspiring new collaborations. This happened recently at the ancient Maya city of Uxbenka.
Conversations of repatriation often fade to the background upon the point of return. Repatriation attempts to signal that wrongs have been righted, and attention shifts to the next artifact held captive. Local initiatives that create open access to archeology, artifacts and museums are the first step to decolonizing institutions that have taken decision-making away from communities.
Before an artifact is even returned, heritage managers must work to repair centuries of divisive actions by building trust through collaborative projects.
Decolonization and reconciliation work is slow because they represent the dismantling of centuries of colonialism and its legacies. What’s happening in Belize is a work in progress. Its citizens pursue diverse self-determined actions along with repatriation as steps toward generational healing and redress.
Meaghan Peuramaki-Brown receives research funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. The Belize Institute of Archaeology, National Institute of Culture and History, permits her archaeological research and related activities. She is a Registered Professional Archaeologist (44090926) and a member of the Canadian Archaeological Association and the Society for American Archaeology.
Sylvia Batty is a co-founder and co-director of Heritage Education Network Belize a 501c-3 registered organization. Sylvia is also a co-founder of Fajina Archaeology Outreach which operates in Belize. Sylvia is a 2021 Museums Association of the Caribbean fellow. She also holds the post of Archaeologist in the Research and Education Department of the Institute of Archaeology in the National Institute of Culture and History under the Ministry of Education, Culture, Science and Technology for the Government of Belize.